To homepage
4.6/5
TrustPilot

Best Double Eyelid Operation Doctors in Turkey for Australians

Compare top Double Eyelid Operation doctors and prices in Turkey. Find your best match here.

Get quotes from 3 top Double Eyelid Operation specialists in Turkey

We'll hand-pick the best doctors based on your needs and budget.

Meet the experts behind this page

Top doctors

41

Turkey

Reviews

14,000+

From real patients

Choose the country with the best prices for doctors' services

Compare prices for Double Eyelid Operation across top countries

Tap a country to view top doctors and prices

Thailand
Turkey
Ukraine
South Korea
Mexico
Czech Republic
AUD $568 - AUD $2,413
AUD $1,136 - AUD $2,129
AUD $1,278 - AUD $2,129
AUD $1,987 - AUD $4,259
AUD $2,129 - AUD $3,549
AUD $2,129 - AUD $3,549
AUD $0
AUD $1,420
AUD $2,839
AUD $4,259

What Bookimed patients actually pay for Double Eyelid Operation in Turkey

Most popular range

$2.5K

$2.75K

$3K

$3.5K

$4K

AUD $4,259 – AUD $4,969

Most patients pay within this range

The exact cost depends on the chosen doctor, technique, areas treated, and your individual needs.

Get a precise quote for your case.

Get free personalised treatment plans and choose the best option. No commitment · No payments for our services

Show first:

938 people have requested a quote last month

Murat Yaman

  • 5 Excellent 15 reviews
  • 11 years of experience
  • Location: Turkey, Istanbul
  • Dr. Murat Yaman is a seasoned plastic and cosmetic surgeon. He is known for his expertise in tummy tuck surgeries and employing advanced surgical techniques for optimal outcomes. He has performed an impressive number of various surgeries, including over 1,500 nose jobs and breast enlargements, 500 facelifts, 1,000 lift surgeries, and around 1,000 liposuctions using VASER lipo technology.

  • Read more
Doctor's visit
Price on request

253 people have requested a quote last month

Muhammet Mustafa Aydinol

  • 5 Excellent 14 reviews
  • 16 years of experience
  • Location: Turkey, Istanbul
  • Clinic:
    4.9
    Dr. MED
  • Dr Muhammet Mustafa Aydinol is a specialist plastic surgeon at Dr. MED Clinic who holds international accreditation for aesthetic procedures.

    • Member of the International Society of Aesthetic Plastic Surgery (ISAPS)
    • Specialises in aesthetic surgery with a focus on facial reconstruction
    • Maintains active membership in the Turkish Society of Plastic, Reconstructive and Aesthetic Surgeons
    • Holds a specialist diploma from Dicle University in plastic and reconstructive surgery
    • Researches pediatric leg reconstruction and advanced breast augmentation techniques
  • Read more
Doctor's visit
Price on request

136 people have requested a quote last month

Yunus Emre Seker

  • 8 years of experience
  • Location: Turkey, Antalya
  • Clinic:
    4.9
    Soraca Med
  • Professor Dr Ömer Özkan, a world pioneer in transplantation, trained Dr Yunus Emre Seker in high-precision reconstructive and aesthetic surgery.

    • Specialises in blepharoplasty and facial rejuvenation at Soraca Med in Antalya
    • Participated in history-making surgical teams for complex face and limb transplants
    • Won second place in a clinical research competition hosted by the Turkish Society of Plastic Surgeons
    • Graduated from Ankara University Faculty of Medicine, one of Turkey's most prestigious schools
    • Former plastic surgery instructor at Adıyaman Training and Research Hospital
  • Read more
Package price fromAUD $2,464

115 people have requested a quote last month

Ilker Manavbaşı

  • 4 Good 5 reviews
  • 25 years of experience
  • accreditation:
  • Location: Turkey, Istanbul
  • The doctor is the youngest member of the prestigious Rhinoplasty Society, which accepts only a limited number of international surgeons. Specializing in functional nasal surgery, facial rejuvenation, mega liposuction, and breast surgery, the doctor has a robust educational background with degrees from Ankara University and Hacettepe University.

    Professional experience includes roles as Chief of the Department of Hand Surgery at Private Irene Hospital, Partner-Surgeon at Professor Dr. Onur Erol's clinic, and Plastic Surgeon at Zeeba Clinic in Cleveland. The doctor has also served as an observer doctor in Finland and Sweden.

    Memberships include the Istanbul Medical Chamber, Turkish Society of Plastic Reconstructive and Aesthetic Surgery, and the Aesthetic Plastic Surgery Association.

  • Read more
Package price fromAUD $3,286

Atilla Hacilar

  • 31 years of experience
  • Location: Turkey, Istanbul
  • Dr Atilla Hacilar is a Cyprus-born plastic surgeon who brings intensive clinical training from the respected Ankara Numune Training and Research Hospital.

    • Specialises in aesthetic and reconstructive surgery at ClinicExpert in Istanbul
    • Spent over a decade as a lead surgeon at İskenderun State Hospital
    • Holds specialised European certification in thread lift and face lift techniques from Belgium
    • Focuses on facial rejuvenation and delicate periorbital aesthetic work
    • Member of the Turkish medical community with extensive public and private surgical experience
  • Read more
Package price fromAUD $4,272

17 people have requested a quote last month

Burak Ergun Tatar

  • 9 years of experience
  • Location: Turkey, Istanbul
  • Dr Burak Ergun Tatar graduated with distinction from Istanbul University and holds a specialised microsurgery fellowship from the Universita Campus Bio-Medico in Rome.

    • Holds a formal Microsurgery Certificate used for high-precision eyelid adjustments
    • Completed residency at the Bagcilar Research and Training Hospital plastic surgery department
    • Awarded by the Scientific and Technological Research Council of Turkey for medical innovation
    • Practises at Medipol Acibadem District Hospital using refined aesthetic reconstructive techniques
    • Certified in medical statistics to ensure evidence-based surgical outcomes
  • Read more
Doctor's visit
Price on request

24 people have requested a quote last month

Cemal Firat

  • 24 years of experience
  • Location: Turkey, Antalya
  • Professor Cemal Firat is a senior specialist at Medical Park Antalya with a distinguished career in microsurgery and maxillofacial reconstruction. He leads complex surgical cases at one of Turkey's largest medical networks.

    • Holds the highest academic rank of Professor at Inonu University Faculty of Medicine
    • Specialises in aesthetic surgery and intricate microsurgical repair
    • Published extensive research on tissue healing and nerve regeneration
    • Expertise includes maxillofacial and reconstructive procedures of the face
  • Read more
Doctor's visit
Price on request

31 people have requested a quote last month

Mohammed Alhelou

  • 7 years of experience
  • Location: Turkey, Istanbul
  • Dr Mohammed Alhelou is a specialist in plastic and reconstructive surgery who focuses on intricate facial procedures at Elixirmed Clinic.

    • Specialises in blepharoplasty and advanced suture techniques for natural results
    • Combines micro-surgery expertise with aesthetic judgement for fine detail work
    • Handles both cosmetic eyelid refinements and reconstructive facial surgery
    • Experienced in treating congenital facial anomalies and skin cancers
  • Read more
Doctor's visit
Price on request

30 people have requested a quote last month

Burak Özkan

  • 5 Excellent 1 review
  • 17 years of experience
  • Location: Turkey, Istanbul
  • Associate Professor Burak Özkan is a FEBOPRAS-certified surgeon with extensive training in Seoul and Tokyo, hubs of expertise for double eyelid surgery.

    • Held a fellowship at Asan Medical Center in Seoul, South Korea
    • Fellow of the European Board of Plastic, Reconstructive and Aesthetic Surgery
    • Specialises in aesthetic eyelid surgery and maxillofacial reconstruction
    • Executive Committee Member of the Turkish Reconstructive Microsurgery Society
    • Recognised with the Young Plastic Surgeons Scholarship from EURAPS
  • Read more
Doctor's visit
Price on request

Hasbi Meral

  • 11 years of experience
  • Location: Turkey, Antalya
  • Op. Dr. Hasbi Mert Meral is a board-certified plastic, reconstructive, and aesthetic surgeon. He has over 10 years of experience and has performed more than 2,000 surgeries. He is certified by the Turkish Society of Plastic, Reconstructive and Aesthetic Surgeons. He is a Fellow of the European Board of Plastic, Reconstructive and Aesthetic Surgery (EBOPRAS). He holds a reconstructive microsurgery certification (2017).

    Current positions: Cayra Clinic and Mert Meral Plastic (since 2023). He previously worked at Private Imperial Hospital in Trabzon and Trabzon Kanuni Training and Research Hospital. His expertise includes rhinoplasty, facial rejuvenation, and blepharoplasty. He also performs breast surgery, abdominoplasty, liposuction, and mommy makeovers. Other focus areas include fat transfer, body contouring, reconstructive surgery for skin cancer, burns, and hand conditions, and scar revision.

  • Read more
Doctor's visit
Price on request

27 people have requested a quote last month

Leyla Arvas

  • 5 Excellent 2 reviews
  • 28 years of experience
  • Location: Turkey, Istanbul
  • Clinic:
    4.7
    Quartz Hospital
  • The doctor graduated from Istanbul University Medical Faculty in 1998 and specialized in Plastic, Reconstructive, and Aesthetic Surgery. She gained significant experience in microsurgery at Taiwan Chang Gung Memorial Hospital and laser treatments at TWMU Hospital in Tokyo. The doctor further honed her skills in face and breast aesthetics at Instituto Javier de Benito in Barcelona.

    As an Assistant Professor at Yeditepe University Hospital, she contributed to the field of plastic surgery and later became a consultant at Bosphorus Anatomica Plastic Surgery Center. She specializes in Rhinoplasty, Blepharoplasty, face lifts, liposuction, and body shaping procedures, utilizing advanced techniques like VASER and LASER liposuction.

  • Read more
Package price fromAUD $3,975

Kamil Yildirim

  • 21 years of experience
  • Location: Turkey, Istanbul
  • Dr Kamil Yildirim is a dedicated specialist in facial surgical applications and cosmetic procedures at Büyük Anadolu Hospitals.

    • Specialises in facial surgery including eyelid and rejuvenation procedures
    • Expertise in botox and mesotherapy for revitalising the eye area
    • Performs both invasive and non-invasive facial shaping techniques
    • Focuses on facial aesthetics including rhinoplasty and body shaping
    • Consults at a major international hospital centre in Turkey
  • Read more
Doctor's visit
Price on request

Emrah Koksal

  • 9 years of experience
  • Location: Turkey, Istanbul
  • Dr Emrah Koksal brings intensive surgical discipline from his training at the Gülhane Military Medical Academy to the Medical Park Göztepe Hospital Complex.

    • Specialised in plastic and reconstructive surgery with a focus on facial aesthetics
    • Member of the International Society of Aesthetic Plastic Surgery (ISAPS)
    • Holds active membership in the Reconstructive Microsurgery Association
    • Affiliated with the Turkish Plastic, Reconstructive and Aesthetic Surgery Association
    • Practises at a major university-affiliated hospital complex in Istanbul
  • Read more
Doctor's visit
Price on request

Ozge Utku Aydemir

  • 8 years of experience
  • Location: Turkey, Istanbul
  • Ozge Utku Aydemir is a European Board-certified specialist who focuses on refined facial aesthetic surgery at Medical Park Bahcelievler Hospital.

    • Holds the prestigious EBOPRAS Part 1 Certification for plastic and reconstructive surgery
    • Highly trained in blepharoplasty and temporal lifts for precise eyelid contouring
    • Completed specialist residency at Ankara Bilkent City Hospital, a major Turkish medical hub
    • Active member of the Turkish Society of Plastic, Reconstructive and Aesthetic Surgery
  • Read more
Doctor's visit
Price on request

Aziz Parspanci

  • 11 years of experience
  • Location: Turkey, Istanbul
  • Dr Aziz Parspanci is a plastic and reconstructive specialist at Medipol University Pendik Hospital with a focus on refined facial aesthetics.

    • Specialises in both upper and lower eyelid surgery to restore a natural appearance
    • Focuses on facial rejuvenation including brow and temporal lifts
    • Skilled in microsurgical reconstruction for complex tissue repair
    • Completed specialist training at Manisa Celal Bayar University
    • Member of the Turkish National Plastic Surgery Congress
  • Read more
Doctor's visit
Price on request

Asli Datli

  • 16 years of experience
  • Location: Turkey, Istanbul
  • Dr Asli Datli is a microsurgery-trained plastic surgeon who completed a prestigious fellowship at the ASAN Medical Centre in Seoul, South Korea.

    • Specialises in facial rejuvenation including endoscopic brow lifts and eyelid procedures
    • Trained in South Korea, the global hub for advanced double eyelid surgery techniques
    • Uses microsurgical precision to handle delicate skin laxity and tissue reconstruction
    • Published researcher in international aesthetic and reconstructive journals
    • Practices at the JCI-accredited Liv Hospital Ulus in Istanbul
  • Read more
Doctor's visit
Price on request

You've viewed 16 of 41 doctors

Choosing a clinic abroad can be stressful. At Bookimed, with over 800K patients helped, we understand your concerns. We know how to find trusted doctors, the best price-quality options, and solutions for even complex cases. We’re here to guide you every step of the way.

Yan Matsiivskiy

Head of Medical Coordinator Team

4300++ patient journeys guided

3 years at Bookimed

278 patients from Turkey have found their doctor through us this month

How you'll get your perfect doctor match

1

2 min Quiz

Tell us your goal, budget, timeline

2

Human Matching + AI

Our algorithm finds matches, coordinator verifies fit

3

Your Options Ready

Compare prices, packages, dates. Chat with your coordinator

Overwhelmed by choices?

Your personal Bookimed coordinator helps you find the perfect surgeon tailored to your needs

  • Supports you 24/7 at every stage
  • Helps match you with the doctor and handles all communication with clinics
  • Coordinates your travel, accommodation, and transfers

Guiding your treatment

Medically trained personal coordinators

Peguy Beaugris
Tetyana Hyrych
Zekra Eldeeb
Victoria Olayinka
Iryna Sydorchuk
Tetiana Ihnatiuk

Choosing the Right Doctor and Clinic: Insider Tips

When selecting a doctor or clinic, keep these key points in mind:
Check credentials
Verify certifications from bodies like ISAPS, JCI, or relevant medical boards
Review success rates
Choose doctors with solid experience and a proven track record in your specific treatment.
Read patient reviews
Browse Bookimed reviews from real patients to learn about their experiences.
Ensure effective communication
Pick clinics that offer language support for a smooth treatment process.
Ask about services
Confirm whether the price includes services such as accommodation, local transfers, and follow-up care to avoid hidden costs.

Bookimed Insights: Top Double Eyelid Operation Specialists in Turkey for Australians (2026)

Bookimed helps Australian patients find top Double Eyelid Operation surgeons in Turkey, collaborating with 41 leading specialists. The doctors in this ranking are selected based on their international credentials, clinical expertise, English proficiency, number of performed cases, and patient outcomes. The 2026 ranking is formed using verified data from actual patient cases — including reviews from Australian travellers — and current programmes from our partner clinics. All prices are displayed in AUD for easy comparison with Double Eyelid Operation costs in Australia.
RankDoctorexperienceGood Fit ForWhat Sets Them ApartClinic & LocationConsultation
#116 years of experienceAesthetic facial reconstructionInternational ISAPS membership ensures he follows global standards for aesthetic surgery. He specialises in facial and reconstructive procedures with a focus on refined surgical outcomes.
Turkey
Price on request
#28 years of experienceHigh-precision eyelid rejuvenationTrained by world-renowned transplant pioneers in ultra-precise surgical techniques. Award-winning researcher with experience in complex reconstructive cases, ensuring balanced and natural results in delicate eyelid procedures.
Turkey
Price on request
#331 years of experienceAesthetic facial rejuvenationBrings over 14 years of state-level surgical leadership. Holds advanced Belgian certification for facial lifting techniques, ensuring a focus on refined, natural-looking periorbital results.
Turkey
Price on request
#49 years of experienceMicrosurgical precision eyelid liftingFellowship-trained in microsurgery in Italy. He uses these high-precision techniques for delicate eyelid work, graduating with distinction from one of Turkey's premier medical schools.
Turkey
Price on request
#524 years of experienceComplex facial reconstruction and microsurgeryAs a Professor of Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery, he brings academic rigour to every case. His background in maxillofacial and tumor surgery ensures a high level of precision for eyelid procedures.
Turkey
Price on request
#67 years of experiencePrecision suture techniquesBrings micro-surgery skills to eyelid procedures for high-precision results. He specialises in advanced suture techniques and reconstructive surgery for complex facial cases.
Turkey
Price on request
#717 years of experienceAsian eyelid surgery and complex blepharoplastyFellowship-trained in Seoul and Tokyo, specialising in precise eyelid aesthetics. He is a FEBOPRAS fellow and sits on the Executive Committee for Reconstructive Microsurgery.
Turkey
Price on request
#821 years of experienceFacial aesthetics and eyelid rejuvenationSpecialises in facial surgical applications with a focus on aesthetic harmony. His expertise spans both surgical eyelid procedures and non-invasive facial fillers and mesotherapy for a cohesive cosmetic result.
Turkey
Price on request
#99 years of experienceAesthetic and reconstructive eyelid surgeryTrained at the prestigious Gülhane Military Medical Academy in plastic and reconstructive surgery. He holds dual memberships in ISAPS and the Reconstructive Microsurgery Association, ensuring high technical standards for delicate eyelid procedures.
Turkey
Price on request
#108 years of experienceForm-focused blepharoplasty and facial aestheticsEuropean Board (EBOPRAS) certified specialist with specific training in advanced eyelid and temple lift techniques. Her microsurgery background ensures a meticulous approach to delicate eye-area procedures.
Turkey
Price on request

FAQ

These FAQs come from real patients seeking medical assistance through Bookimed. Answers are given by experienced medical coordinators and trusted clinic representatives.

What qualifications should I look for in a Turkish doctor performing a double eyelid operation?

Qualified Turkish surgeons for double eyelid surgery hold specialization in Plastic, Reconstructive, and Aesthetic Surgery. Look for doctors with international training and EBOPRAS or ISAPS certification. These credentials demonstrate mastery of delicate eyelid anatomy and advanced microsurgical techniques required for precise, natural-looking folds.

  • Specialization certificates: Surgeons must hold a formal title in Plastic, Reconstructive, and Aesthetic Surgery.
  • International fellowships: Prioritize doctors with specialized training in South Korea, Japan, or Taiwan.
  • Board certifications: Top surgeons hold Turkish or European Board (EBOPRAS) certifications for quality.
  • Facility accreditation: Ensure the surgeon operates in JCI-accredited hospitals with full emergency support.

Bookimed Expert Insight: Data shows a high value in surgeons with specific East Asian training. Dr. Asli Datli at Liv Hospital Ulus completed a microsurgery fellowship in Seoul. Dr. Leyla Arvas studied at Taiwan’s top microsurgery center. These specific international backgrounds are vital for understanding Asian eyelid anatomy beyond general blepharoplasty.

Patient Consensus: Patients emphasize that top surgeons spend time discussing crease height and ptosis before surgery. They note that the best results come from doctors who focus on natural symmetry. Many were surprised by how easy the logistics were with dedicated drivers and hospital staff.

Should I choose a general plastic surgeon or an ophthalmologist for a double-eyelid operation in Turkey?

Choosing between a plastic surgeon and an ophthalmologist depends on your aesthetic goals and ocular health. Oculoplastic surgeons focus on eye protection and function. General plastic surgeons in Turkey often specialize in facial harmony and refined crease design. Both can deliver excellent results if they have specific training in Asian blepharoplasty.
  • Specific training: Look for surgeons with dedicated microsurgery fellowships from leading centers in Asia.
  • Microsurgery expertise: Qualified Turkish surgeons use ultra-fine sutures to manipulate delicate eyelid muscles accurately.
  • Facial balance: Plastic surgeons are better suited for combining eyelid work with rhinoplasty or fat grafting.
  • Functional safety: Specialized eyelid surgeons prioritize blink function and cornea lubrication during the procedure.

Bookimed Expert Insight: Turkish plastic surgeons frequently bridge the gap between aesthetics and function through international fellowships. For example, Dr. Asli Datli at Liv Hospital Ulus and Dr. Leyla Arvas at Quartz Hospital both completed specialized microsurgery training in Seoul and Taiwan. This Asian-specific exposure is a non-obvious indicator of expertise in creating natural-looking creases while protecting eye health.

Patient Consensus: Patients note that seeing clear before-and-after photos of similar ethnic features is more important than a doctor's broad title. They emphasize asking all detailed questions during the first meeting, as surgeon access is sometimes limited after the operation. Many felt relieved when drivers and translators managed the logistics, allowing them to focus entirely on recovery.

Do Turkish doctors have specific experience with Asian Blepharoplasty anatomy?

Turkish surgeons possess specialized experience with Asian blepharoplasty through advanced international training and high patient volumes. Leading experts hold fellowships from top institutions in Seoul and Taiwan. They precisely manage unique anatomical factors like thicker eyelid skin and specialized fat distribution to create natural results.

  • International training: Dr. Asli Datli completed a specialized microsurgery fellowship at ASAN Medical Centre in Seoul.
  • Asian-centric expertise: Dr. Leyla Arvas trained at Taiwan Chang Gung Memorial Hospital for advanced microsurgery techniques.
  • Focused specializations: Dr. Yavuz Özsular specifically focuses on Asian eyelid surgery within his Istanbul practice.
  • Dual board certification: Dr. Mehmet Mustafa Kiyar holds certifications from both Turkish and European plastic surgery boards.

Bookimed Expert Insight: Data shows that top-tier Turkish surgeons for this procedure often seek specific East Asian clinical experience. For example, Dr. Leyla Arvas at Quartz Hospital trained in both Taiwan and Japan. Dr. Asli Datli at Liv Hospital Ulus spent a year in South Korea. This international exposure allows them to master non-Western crease heights and internal suture anchoring techniques.

Patient Consensus: Patients note it is important to see specific before-and-after photos of Asian eyelid cases beforehand. They say the process works like clockwork with dedicated drivers and supportive clinic staff. Those who chose specialists mentions feeling relieved that the surgeon understood their specific desire for a natural-looking crease.

How can I verify a Turkish doctor’s surgical track record for double-eyelid surgery?

Verifying a Turkish surgeon for double eyelid surgery involves confirming board certification and specialized training in Asian anatomy. Qualified specialists typically hold Turkish Board certification (TPRCD) or European Board (EBOPRAS) credentials. Top doctors often complete fellowships in regions like Taiwan or Japan to master precise eyelid techniques.

  • Board certification: Confirm the surgeon holds Turkish Society of Plastic Reconstructive and Aesthetic Surgery (TPCD) membership.
  • International credentials: Look for International Society of Aesthetic Plastic Surgery (ISAPS) membership for global quality standards.
  • Anatomy training: Seek surgeons with specialized training in Asian blepharoplasty from microsurgery centers in Asia.
  • Hospital accreditation: Ensure the facility holds JCI or Turkish Ministry of Health international tourism certification.

Bookimed Expert Insight: Data shows that dual training in microsurgery and aesthetics is a key differentiator in Turkey. For example, Dr. Leyla Arvas at Quartz Hospital studied at Taiwan Chang Gung Memorial Hospital and in Tokyo. This specific orbital anatomy training is vital for the complexity of double eyelid procedures compared to standard blepharoplasty.

Patient Consensus: Patients note it is important to see the operating surgeon for an in-depth initial consultation. They emphasize checking for detailed explanations regarding crease height and scarring before the procedure begins. Many were pleased when all logistics, like dedicated drivers and hotel stays, worked like clockwork.

How do Turkish doctors handle consultations and follow-up care for international patients?

Turkish doctors manage international care through remote digital assessments followed by intensive in-person clinical exams. Specialists review medical records and photos before travel to finalize surgical plans. This process bridges the gap between digital consultations and hands-on hospital care for patients.

  • Virtual evaluations: Doctors review high-resolution photos and health history through secure digital platforms.
  • Bilingual coordination: Multilingual teams at JCI-accredited clinics assist with medical translation and scheduling.
  • On-site validation: Surgeons perform detailed clinical exams upon arrival to confirm the virtual diagnosis.
  • Remote monitoring: Most surgical packages include 3 to 6 months of digital follow-up care.

Bookimed Expert Insight: Data shows that top Istanbul surgeons, like Dr. Leyla Arvas and Dr. Asli Datli, utilize specialized international training to handle diverse patient needs. Dr. Arvas brings Asian eyelid anatomy expertise from Taiwan. Dr. Datli applies microsurgical precision learned in Seoul. These specific international backgrounds allow for more tailored recovery plans for patients from different regions.

Patient Consensus: Patients note that initial contact is very fast and efficient through digital channels. While the time with the primary surgeon can be brief, dedicated drivers and hotel staff make the logistics feel seamless. Many suggest having recovery questions ready for the first meeting to get the most from the consultation.